General Contact

Jeanette Hvarregaard

DRUID Secretary

druid@druid.dk

 

DRUID is associated with the journal Industry and Innovation, published by Routledge. Currently in its 19th year and with 8 annual issues, Industry and Innovation's 2010 impact factor in Thomson Reuters' Social Science Citation Index was 1.83, 40/304 (Economics), 49/140 (Management). Industry and Innovation has a global editorial board of distinguished innovation scholars and publishes high-quality original scholarship on tendencies in industrial dynamics, such as the emergence of new industries; restructuring of existing industries; rise of new institutional and organizational forms; globalization; and other aspects of geographical organization.

 

 

 

 

DRUID Debates (Video)

The DRUID Debates aim at stimulating civilized controversy and advance the field of industrial dynamics by clarifying and developing intellectual positions in fundamental or currently heated debates.

The debates are structured to help identify common grounds and lines of division within the field, and  to encourage conference participants and subsequent website viewers to take sides and become persuaded by arguments presented.

 

 

NEOCLASSICAL ECONOMICS AND INNOVATION

June 21, 2012, Moderator: Keld Laursen

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that mainstream neoclassical economic theory does not contribute positively to innovation studies"

Speaking FOR the motion: Giovanni Dosi and Sidney Winter

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Paul Stoneman and Otto Toivanen

 

EXPLORATION / EXPLOITATION 

June 20, 2012, Moderator: Mark Lorenzen

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that the exploration/exploitation trade-off is a helpful metaphor, but has little value in informing research that is relevant to organizations/managers"

Speaking FOR the motion: Marco Giarratana and Lori Rosenkopf

Speaking AGAINST the motion: John Cantwell  and Ram Mudambi

 

IPR AND GROWTH

June 19, 2012, Moderator: Mette P. Knudsen

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that (the current structure of) intellectual property rights are a serious impediment to economic progress"

Speaking FOR the motion: Eric von Hippel  and Georg von Krogh

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Anita McGahan and Scott Stern  

 

ROLE OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH

June 16, 2011, Moderator: Anita McGahan

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes the primary role of empirical researchers is to test theories"

Speaking FOR the motion: Michael Ryall and Gerard George

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Michael Jensen and Michelle Gittelman

 

CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY

June 15, 2011, Moderator: Marco Giarratana

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that there is little firm investments in social values or corporate social responsibility without the aim of value creation"

Speaking FOR the motion: Andrea Fosfuri and Jean Philippe Bonardi

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Shawn Berman and Stephen Brammer

 

UNIVERSITY PATENTING

June 18, 2010, Moderator: Francesco Lissoni

Motion: ”Let it be resolved that this conference believes that University Patenting increasingly impede knowledge sharing and overall economic growth”

A vote where the audience indicates its initial stand on the motion

Speaking for the motion: Martin Kenney and Arvids A. Ziedonis

Speaking against the motion: Marie Thusby and Ben Martin

Rebuttals 
A vote where the audience indicates its concluding stand on the motion

 

ENTREPRENEURSHIP

June 17, 2010, Moderator: Erkko Autio

Motion: “Let it be resolved that this conference believes that a significant part of entrepreneurship is innate” (to be finalized by the debaters)

A vote where the audience indicates its initial stand on the motion

Speaking FOR the motion: Nicolas Nicolau and Scott Shane

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Alfonso Gambardella and Peter Thompson

Rebuttals 
A vote where the audience indicates its concluding stand on the motion

 

EVOLUTIONARY PROCESSES

June 19, 2009, Moderator: Mark Dodgson

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that empirical evidence on industrial dynamics favors organizational ecology"

Speaking FOR the motion: Laszlo Polos and Stanislav D. Dobrev

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Giovanni Dosi and Bart Verspagen

 

PREDICTION

June 17, 2009, Moderator: David Gann

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that the notion of prediction has high value as a criterion for research in social sciences"

Speaking FOR the motion: Will Mitchell and Anne Marie Knott

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Geoffrey M. Hodgson and Paul Nightingale

 

THE SCIENTIFIC VALUE OF GAME THEORY

June 20, 2008, Moderator: Thorbjørn Knudsen

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that sophisticated analyses based on game theory have made no significant contribution to the understanding of real questions of business strategy"

Speaking FOR the motion: Sidney G. Winter and Dan Levinthal

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Bruno Cassiman and Peter Zemsky

 

NETWORKS

June 19, 2008, Moderator: Olav Sorenson

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that network dynamics are an essential variable in any explanation of innovation"

Speaking FOR the motion: Walter W. Powell and Jason Owen-Smith

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Francesco Lissoni and Elaine Romanelli

 

PATENTS

June 18, 2008, Moderator: Anita McGahan

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that in order to improve the quality and impact of empirical research on industry dynamics we should discourage the use of patent data measure innovation."

Speaking FOR the motion: Maryann Feldman and Myriam Mariani

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Joanne Oxley and Bronwyn Hall

 

DYNAMICS CAPABILITIES and ADAPTATION

June 20, 2007, Moderator: Peter Maskell

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conferences believes that the study of dynamic capabilities leads to a dead end. Rather, to further our understanding of firm performance we need to study organizational adaptation rather than dynamic capabilities".

Speaking FOR the motion: Dan Levinthal and William C. Ocasio

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Gautam Ahuja and Kathleen Eisenhardt

 

METHODOLOGICAL INDIVIDUALISM versus SCIENTIFIC PROGRESS

June 19, 2007, Moderator: Keld Laursen

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that the lack of methodological individualism applied in strategy research seriously limits scientific progress in the field."

Speaking FOR the motion: Peter Abel and Nicolai Foss

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Sidney G. Winter and Thorbjørn Knudsen

 

USERS and INNOVATION 

June 20, 2006, Moderator: Ammon Salter

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that users are the primary source of innovations in the economy and therefore the central role of business firms is to enable and harness these users' innovations rather than trying to innovate for them"

Speaking FOR the motion: Dietmar Harhoff and Lars Bo Jeppesen

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Deborah Dougherty and Gautam Ahuja

 

SOCIAL NETWORKS

June 19, 2006. Moderator: Virginia Acha

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that social networks play a crucial role in facilitating regional economic development and the emergence and persistence of industrial clusters"

Speaking FOR the motion: Olav Sorenson and Jesper B. Sørensen

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Alfonso Gambardella and Scott Stern

 

FIRM STRATEGY OR INDUSTRY AFFILIATION?

June 29, 2005. Moderator: Keld Laursen

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that industry structure is a central determinant of firm performance and that the scope for firm strategy is limited accordingly"

Speaking FOR the motion: Anita McGahan and Janet Bercovitz

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Alfonso Gambardella and Sidney Winter

 

OFFSHORING INTELLECTUAL LABOUR

June 28, 2005  Moderator: Peter Maskell

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that offshoring intellectual labour is the first stage in the true globalisation of innovation and the end to the knowledge-based comparative advantage of currently developed countries"

Speaking FOR  the motion: Daniele Archibugi and Suma S. Athreye

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Michael Storper and Meric Gertler

 

OPEN INNOVATION 

June 27, 2005 Moderator: Jens Frøslev Christensen  

Motion: "Let it be resolved that this conference believes that Open Innovation is a broadly expanding new paradigm in managing innovation implying that the scope for tight appropriability regimes and core competencies is decreasing"

Speaking FOR the motion: Henry Chesbrough and Richard N. Langlois

Speaking AGAINST the motion: Constance Helfat and Ammon Salter

Key Notes (Video)

Alfonson Gambardella: "Strategies for inventing: How large numbers can affect cherry-picking"
June 15, 2011. Chair: Marion Pötz

Daniel A. Levinthal: "Revisiting the Problem of Organizational Gaols: From Problems of conflict to Problems of Direction"
June 16, 2010. Chair: Ammon Salter

Steven Klepper: "Intra-Industry Spinoffs and the Formation of Clusters"
June 18, 2008. Chair: Michael S. Dahl

Bo Carlsson: "Industrial Dynamics: A Review of the Literature 1985-2000"
June 19, 2008. Chair: Bent Dalum

Eric von Hippel: "The Major Role of Clinicians in th Discovery of Off-Label Drug Therapies"
June 18, 2007 Chair: Christoph Hienerth

Sidney Winter: "Replicating Organizational Knowledge: Principles or Templates?"
June 18, 2006 Chair: Ina Drejer

Stan Metcalfe: "The Evolution of Industrial Dynamics"
June 27, 2005 Chair: Lee Davies. Discussant: Esben Sloth Andersen. 

Plenary Paper Presentations (Video)

Learning, Experience and Knowledge, June 17, 2010. Chair: David Gann
Jaideep Anand: "Does Experience Imply Learning? (co-authored with Louis Mulotte)
Phanish Puranam: "Expeditions Without Maps: Why Faulty Initial Representations May Be Useful in Joint Discovery Problems" (co-authored with Murali Swamy)
Jaideep Prabhu: "Patterns in the Global Location of R&D Centres by the World's Largest Firms: The Role of India and China"
Discussants: Margaret Dalziel and Christopher Tucci
Questions and answers

 

Organizing for Innovation (Sponsored by UK Innovation Research Centre), June 16, 2011. Chair: Alan Hughes
Martin Kilduff: "The Production of New Knowledge in Organizations: A Philosophy of Science Approach"
Simoni Ferriani: "The Social Structure of Creativity: Social Networks and Rewards in the Holywood Film Industry"
Bruce Tether: "Turning Digital: Diversification in UK Design consultancy Services" (co-authored with Cher Li, Andrea Mina and Karl Wennberg)
Discussants: Bettina Peters and Gautam Ahuja
Questions and answers

 

Capabilities and New Ventures. June 16, 2010. Chair Aija Leiponen
Jack A. Nickerson: "Designing a Dynamic Capability ofr Strategic Problem Formulation"
Christoph Zott: "The Affective Roots of Resource-based Theory: How Founders' Emotion Regulation Enables resource Creation in Firms"
Zoltán J. Acs: "The Global Entrepreneurship and Development Index (GEDI)" (co-authored with László Szerb)
Discussants: Toke Reichstein and Bart Clarysse
Question and answers

 

Understanding Open and distributed Innovation (Sponsored by the UK Innovation Research Centre), June 16, 2010. Chair Andy Cosh
Carliss Y. Baldwin: "Modeling a Paradigm Shift: From Producer Innovation to User and Open Collaborative Innovation" (co-authored with Eric von Hippel)
David Waguespack: "Status, Quality and Attention: What's in a (Missing) Name? (co-authored with Tim Simcoe)
Joachim Henkel: "Patent Trolls on Markets for Technology - An Empirical Analysis of Troll's Patent Acquisitions" (co-authored with Timo Fischer)
Discussants: Anita McGahan and Steven Roper
Questions and answers

 

Industry Dynamics and Resource Advantage, June 17, 2009. Chair: Nils Stieglitz
Michael Lenox: Interdependencies, Competitive Dynamics, and Firm Choice of Innovation Policy (Co-authored with Scott Rockart)
Daniel Snow: Demand Heterogeneity and Graceful Tehcnology Retreats: a New Perspective on Responding to Dominant Technological Threats (Co-authored with Ron Adner)
Thorbjörn Knudsen: The Role of Scale Adjustment in Industry Dynamics (Co-authored with Sidney Winter and Dan Levinthal)
Discussants: Michael Jacobides and Luigi Marengo

Economic Geography Frontiers, June 19, 2008. Chair: Peter Maskell
AnnaLee Saxenian: "Venture Capital in the "Periphery": The New Argonauts, Global Search and Local Institution Building"
Michael Storper: "The Economics of Context"
Meric S. Gertler: "Buzz without being there?"
Discussants: Jim Love and Stefano Breschi

 

Entrepreneurship, June 18, 2008. Chair: Serden Özcan
Jesper Sørensen: "Competence and Commitment: Employer Size and Entrepreneurial Endurance"
Rajshree Agarwal: "The Process of Creative Construction: Implications for Knowledge Management, Strategic Entrepreneurship and Economic Growth"
Ramana Nanda: "Democratizing Entry: Banking Deregulations, Financing Constraints and Entrepreneurship"
Discussants: Toke Reichstein and Scott Stern

 

Markets for Technology, June 18, 2008. Chair: Marco Giarratana
Alfonso Gambardella: "Ideas for Rent: An Overview of Markets for Technology"
Scott Stern: "Patents, Papers & Privacy: The disclosure of scientific and commercial knowledge"
Sadao Nagaoka: "An analysis of unilateral and cross-licensing: new evidence from the inventor survey in Japan"
Discussants: Gautam Ahuja and Anita McGahan

 

Signals and Syndicates, June 18, 2007. Chair: Mark Dodgson
David Hsu: "The Signaling Value of Patents: Evidence from Semiconductor Start-ups"
David Audretsch: "Nascent Entrepreneurs, Innovation and External Finance"
Anita McGahan: "The More the Merrier: Institutions and Syndicate Size in Venture Capital Investments"
Discussants: Anne Marie Knott and Toke Reichstein

Panel Debates (Video)

Entrepreneurship Research – Present and Future

June 17, 2008, Chair Maryann Feldman

Panel participants: Scott Stern, Steven Klepper, Woody Powell, Elaine Romanelli and Nicos Nicolaou

 

Competition Policy in Dynamic, Innovation-led Markets

June 27, 2005 . Chair: Peter Møllgaard.  

Round table discussion on: "How do we best deal with R&D cooperation, research consortia, research joint ventures and R&D alliances?"

Panel participants: Claes Bengtsson, Sven Hylleberg, Luke Froeb and Peter Møllgaard

Director's Conference Welcome

Peter Maskell, June 16, 2010

 

Peter Maskell, June 17, 2009

 

Peter Maskell, June 18, 2008

 

Peter Maskell, June 18, 2007

 

Peter Maskell, June 18, 2006 

 

Peter Maskell , June 25, 2005